Original Character Creation Avoiding The Horrible Pitfalls

Original characters (OCs) are a fantastic way for creators to express their creativity and connect with audiences on a deeper level. However, the world of OCs isn't always sunshine and rainbows. Sometimes, things can get a little… well, horrible. Let's dive into why that might be, exploring some common pitfalls and how to avoid them, ensuring your OCs are a source of joy rather than cringe.

The Allure and the Abyss of Original Characters

Original characters are the heart and soul of countless fan works, from fanfiction and fanart to original stories and games. They allow creators to inject their unique perspectives and ideas into existing universes or build entirely new worlds from scratch. The possibilities are endless, and that’s part of what makes OCs so appealing. However, the very freedom that makes OCs so exciting can also lead to some major pitfalls. Creating a compelling OC requires careful consideration, thoughtful development, and a healthy dose of self-awareness. Without these elements, an OC can quickly become a caricature, a cliché, or even outright offensive.

One of the most common issues arises when OCs become Mary Sues or Gary Stus. These characters are often idealized versions of their creators, possessing a laundry list of skills, talents, and virtues, while lacking any real flaws or weaknesses. They effortlessly excel in every situation, attract the admiration of all around them, and generally disrupt the established narrative by being too perfect. While there’s nothing wrong with wanting to create a powerful or capable character, it’s crucial to balance strengths with vulnerabilities. A character who never struggles, never fails, and never makes mistakes is ultimately a boring character. Think about your favorite heroes and heroines – what makes them compelling? It’s often their imperfections, their doubts, and their moments of vulnerability that make them relatable and human. Another common pitfall is creating OCs that are simply too derivative. It’s natural to draw inspiration from existing characters and stories, but an OC should ultimately be their own person. If your character is essentially a carbon copy of a popular character with a different name, it’s unlikely to resonate with audiences. Strive for originality, even if it means stepping outside your comfort zone. Think about unique backstories, motivations, and personality quirks that will set your OC apart. Don’t be afraid to experiment and challenge yourself to create something truly fresh and exciting. Remember, the goal is to add to the existing narrative, not to simply replicate it. Creating a compelling OC is a balancing act. It requires a blend of creativity, originality, and self-awareness. By understanding the common pitfalls and actively working to avoid them, you can create OCs that are not only memorable but also meaningful.

Common Pitfalls in OC Creation

Let's break down some specific problems that can make an original character fall flat, or worse, become actively disliked. Recognizing these pitfalls is the first step to avoiding them. We'll cover everything from the dreaded Mary Sue to the dangers of over-sexualization and the importance of cultural sensitivity.

The Mary Sue/Gary Stu Syndrome

The infamous Mary Sue (female) and Gary Stu (male) are probably the most well-known pitfalls in OC creation. These characters are often ridiculously perfect – they're exceptionally skilled, incredibly attractive, universally liked, and have tragic backstories that somehow make them even more special. They rarely face genuine challenges and always seem to come out on top, often overshadowing the original cast in their own story. Guys, no one likes a character who's too good to be true! It’s crucial to ground your character with believable flaws and vulnerabilities. Giving your OC weaknesses makes them relatable and allows for character growth and development. Think about what your character struggles with – is it a physical limitation, a personality flaw, or a past trauma? How do these struggles impact their decisions and actions? Remember, characters who overcome adversity are far more compelling than those who are effortlessly perfect. Mary Sues often feel like wish-fulfillment fantasies rather than fully realized characters. They lack depth and nuance, and their perfection often feels forced and unrealistic. A well-rounded character, on the other hand, has both strengths and weaknesses, successes and failures. They make mistakes, they learn from their experiences, and they evolve over time. This dynamic nature is what makes them interesting and engaging to audiences. Furthermore, the presence of a Mary Sue can disrupt the narrative of the original story. Their overwhelming competence and popularity can overshadow the existing characters, making them feel less important or even irrelevant. This can be frustrating for fans of the original work, as it detracts from the established dynamics and relationships. To avoid the Mary Sue trap, be honest with yourself about your character's limitations. Don't be afraid to give them flaws, both physical and emotional. Make them work for their successes, and let them experience setbacks and failures. A character who has to overcome challenges is far more compelling than one who is effortlessly perfect.

Overpowered and Underdeveloped

Another common issue is creating an OC who is incredibly powerful but lacks the emotional depth to back it up. A character with godlike abilities is only interesting if they have compelling reasons for using those abilities – and equally compelling limitations. What are the consequences of their power? What do they value? What are their fears? These are the questions that make a powerful character relatable. Overpowered characters often suffer from a lack of vulnerability, which makes it difficult for audiences to connect with them. If a character can effortlessly overcome any obstacle, there’s little tension or suspense in their story. The audience knows they’ll always win, which can lead to a sense of detachment and disinterest. A well-developed character, on the other hand, has internal conflicts and external challenges that create dramatic tension. They face difficult choices, make mistakes, and learn from their experiences. This vulnerability is what makes them human, even if they possess extraordinary abilities. Furthermore, an overpowered character can disrupt the balance of the narrative, making other characters feel insignificant. If your OC can solve every problem single-handedly, the contributions of the original cast may seem trivial. This can be frustrating for fans of the original work, as it diminishes the importance of the characters they already care about. Think about characters like Superman – he’s incredibly powerful, but his stories are compelling because of his internal struggles and his commitment to using his powers for good. His vulnerability lies in his compassion and his fear of losing control. This balance of power and vulnerability is what makes him a relatable and enduring character. Similarly, an OC can be incredibly strong and capable, but they should also have weaknesses and vulnerabilities that make them human. These weaknesses can be physical, emotional, or even moral. The key is to create a character who is both powerful and relatable, someone who audiences can root for even when they’re struggling. Creating an interesting character goes beyond just giving them cool powers. It's about crafting a well-rounded individual with a compelling backstory, relatable motivations, and believable flaws. A character's strengths are only as interesting as their weaknesses.

The Tragedy Backstory Trap

We all love a character with a compelling backstory, but sometimes, OC creators go overboard. A tragic backstory can be a powerful motivator, but it shouldn't be the only thing that defines your character. If your OC's entire personality revolves around their traumatic past, they risk becoming one-dimensional and predictable. The key is to use the backstory as a starting point for character development, not as the entire character. The tragedy backstory trap is a common pitfall in OC creation, and it stems from the desire to create a character that is both sympathetic and complex. However, an overreliance on tragic events can lead to a character that is emotionally stunted and lacks the ability to move forward. A truly compelling character is one who has learned to cope with their past and has found ways to grow and heal. Think about how your character has been shaped by their past experiences, but also consider what they have done to overcome those experiences. What are their coping mechanisms? What are their goals for the future? These are the questions that will help you create a character that is more than just their tragic backstory. It’s also important to avoid making the tragedy the sole reason for your character's actions. If every decision they make is directly tied to their past trauma, they risk becoming predictable and one-dimensional. Instead, consider how their past has influenced their values, their beliefs, and their relationships. How does it affect their decision-making process? How does it shape their interactions with others? By exploring these nuances, you can create a character that is both relatable and complex. A well-developed character is one who has learned from their past but is not defined by it. They have found ways to integrate their experiences into their present lives and are actively working towards a better future. This resilience and ability to grow is what makes them compelling and relatable to audiences. Don't be afraid to explore the lighter aspects of your character's personality as well. A character who is constantly brooding and dwelling on their past can become tiresome to read about. Give them moments of joy, humor, and connection with others. Show them pursuing their passions and achieving their goals. These moments of lightness will make their struggles feel more meaningful and their triumphs more rewarding.

The Over-Sexualization Issue

This is a big one. An original character's appearance should be appropriate for the story and the character's personality. If you're sexualizing your OC just for the sake of it, or if their appearance clashes with their role and behavior, it can be off-putting. This is especially important when dealing with underage characters. Remember, a character's worth isn't determined by their attractiveness. Over-sexualization in OC creation is a complex issue with many layers. It often stems from a desire to create a character that is both appealing and powerful, but it can easily cross the line into objectification. A character who is primarily defined by their physical appearance risks being reduced to a mere object of desire, losing their agency and depth in the process. One of the key things to consider is the character's agency. Are they actively participating in their own story, or are they simply being acted upon by others? An over-sexualized character often lacks agency, as their actions are driven by their physical appearance rather than their own desires and motivations. They may be subjected to unwanted attention, objectification, or even exploitation, without having the power to change their circumstances. This lack of agency can be deeply disempowering for both the character and the audience. It’s also crucial to consider the impact of over-sexualization on the overall narrative. If a character's physical appearance becomes the central focus of the story, it can overshadow other important themes and plot points. The story may become less about character development and more about physical appearance, which can be both limiting and problematic. Furthermore, over-sexualization can perpetuate harmful stereotypes and contribute to a culture of objectification. It can send the message that a person's worth is primarily determined by their physical attractiveness, which is both inaccurate and damaging. This is particularly concerning when it comes to underage characters, as it can normalize the sexualization of children and contribute to the risk of abuse. Creating a compelling and nuanced character involves much more than just their physical appearance. It requires careful consideration of their personality, their motivations, their relationships, and their role in the story. A well-developed character is one who is complex, multi-faceted, and capable of making their own choices. They are not simply objects to be admired or desired; they are individuals with their own unique stories to tell.

Cultural Appropriation and Stereotypes

This is another area where original character creators need to tread carefully. Borrowing elements from other cultures can enrich your character, but it's crucial to do so respectfully and with proper research. Avoid perpetuating harmful stereotypes and ensure you understand the cultural significance of the elements you're incorporating. Cultural appropriation is a complex issue that arises when members of a dominant culture take elements from a marginalized culture without understanding or respecting their original context. This can lead to the trivialization and commercialization of cultural practices, as well as the perpetuation of harmful stereotypes. In OC creation, cultural appropriation can manifest in a number of ways, such as using cultural clothing, symbols, or traditions without understanding their significance, or portraying characters from marginalized cultures in a stereotypical or inaccurate way. This can be deeply offensive to members of the culture being appropriated, as it erases their identity and reduces their culture to a mere costume or trope. One of the most important things to consider is the power dynamic between the cultures involved. If you are creating a character from a marginalized culture, it’s crucial to do your research and ensure that you are portraying them in a way that is respectful and authentic. This means avoiding stereotypes and clichés, and instead focusing on the character's individuality and humanity. It also means being mindful of the historical and social context in which the character exists, and avoiding the temptation to romanticize or exoticize their culture. If you are borrowing elements from a culture that is not your own, it’s essential to understand their meaning and significance before incorporating them into your character. This means going beyond surface-level research and engaging with members of the culture in a meaningful way. Listen to their perspectives, learn from their experiences, and be open to feedback and criticism. It’s also important to be mindful of the potential for harm. Even if your intentions are good, your actions can still have a negative impact on others. Before incorporating cultural elements into your OC, ask yourself: Am I perpetuating stereotypes? Am I trivializing or commercializing cultural practices? Am I speaking over or erasing the voices of marginalized communities? If the answer to any of these questions is yes, it’s time to re-evaluate your approach. Creating diverse and inclusive characters is a worthy goal, but it’s crucial to do so in a way that is respectful and ethical. This means doing your research, engaging with marginalized communities, and being mindful of the potential for harm.

How to Create Amazing OCs (That Don't Suck!)

Okay, so we've covered the horrible stuff. Now let's talk about the good stuff! How do you create original characters that are compelling, engaging, and loved by audiences? It's all about thoughtful planning and execution.

Start with a Strong Concept

What's the core idea behind your original character? What makes them unique? What role do they play in the story? A strong concept is the foundation for a great OC. Think about what kind of story you want to tell and what kind of character would best serve that story. Are you looking for a hero, a villain, a sidekick, or something else entirely? What are their strengths and weaknesses? What are their motivations and goals? A strong concept will give you a clear direction for your character development and help you avoid common pitfalls. It's also important to consider the character's place within the existing world. How do they fit into the established dynamics and relationships? What are their connections to the other characters? These questions will help you create a character that feels like a natural part of the story, rather than a tacked-on addition. Don’t be afraid to challenge yourself and experiment with different ideas. Sometimes, the most compelling characters are the ones who defy expectations and break the mold. Think about characters like Loki from the Marvel Cinematic Universe – he’s a villain, but he’s also charismatic, complex, and deeply relatable. His unique personality and motivations are what make him such a compelling character. Start by brainstorming a variety of concepts, and then narrow down your choices based on what resonates with you the most. Consider what kind of character you would be most excited to write about, and what kind of character would best serve the story you want to tell. Once you have a strong concept in mind, you can start to flesh out the details and bring your OC to life. Remember, a great character is more than just a collection of traits and abilities – it’s a living, breathing individual with their own unique story to tell.

Develop a Believable Backstory

As we discussed earlier, a tragic backstory isn't mandatory, but a backstory is crucial. What experiences shaped your character into the person they are today? What are their key relationships? What are their hopes and fears? A well-developed backstory provides context and motivation for your character's actions. A believable backstory is the bedrock of a compelling character. It provides the foundation for their personality, motivations, and relationships. Without a well-developed backstory, your character may feel flat and one-dimensional, lacking the depth and complexity that make them relatable to audiences. Think about the major events that have shaped your character's life. What are the defining moments that have influenced their decisions and actions? What are their earliest memories? What are the relationships that have had the greatest impact on them? These are the questions that will help you create a rich and nuanced backstory that adds depth to your character. It's also important to consider the character's cultural background and upbringing. What are their cultural values and beliefs? What are the traditions and customs that they have been raised with? These factors can significantly influence a character's personality and worldview, and can add a layer of authenticity to their story. Don’t be afraid to explore the darker aspects of your character's past, but be mindful of the potential for trauma and its impact on their development. A traumatic experience can be a powerful motivator, but it should not be the sole defining characteristic of your character. Instead, consider how they have coped with their trauma, and how it has shaped their resilience and strength. Remember, a believable backstory is not just a collection of events – it’s a story in itself. It should have its own narrative arc, with a beginning, middle, and end. It should reveal important details about your character's personality, motivations, and relationships, and should provide a context for their actions in the present. Take your time to develop your character's backstory, and don’t be afraid to revise it as you learn more about them. The more effort you put into creating a believable backstory, the more compelling your character will be.

Give Them Flaws and Weaknesses

Perfection is boring. Give your OC flaws! It makes them relatable and allows for character growth. What are they bad at? What are they afraid of? What mistakes do they make? These imperfections are what make a character human. Flaws and weaknesses are the cornerstones of compelling characters. They add depth, complexity, and relatability, making your OC more than just a collection of traits and abilities. A character without flaws is often seen as a Mary Sue or Gary Stu, lacking the vulnerability and humanity that make them interesting to audiences. Think about the flaws that will make your character unique and believable. Are they insecure, arrogant, impulsive, or overly cautious? Do they have a difficult time trusting others? Do they struggle with their temper? These imperfections can create conflict and tension in your story, and can provide opportunities for character growth and development. It's also important to consider the impact of your character's flaws on their relationships with others. How do their imperfections affect their interactions with family, friends, and romantic partners? Do they struggle to communicate their feelings? Do they have a tendency to push people away? These questions will help you create a character that is both flawed and relatable, someone who audiences can root for even when they make mistakes. Don’t be afraid to give your character weaknesses as well. A character who is too powerful or capable can become boring and predictable. What are their physical limitations? What are their emotional vulnerabilities? What are their moral weaknesses? These vulnerabilities can create stakes and tension in your story, and can make your character's victories feel more meaningful. Remember, flaws and weaknesses are not a sign of poor character development – they are an essential part of creating a compelling and believable OC. Embrace your character's imperfections, and use them to create a story that is both engaging and thought-provoking. The most memorable characters are often the ones who are flawed and human, someone who audiences can connect with on a deeper level.

Make Them Original

This seems obvious, but it's worth emphasizing. Avoid clichés and stereotypes. Strive for originality in your character's personality, backstory, and motivations. What unique perspective do they bring to the story? Originality is the lifeblood of compelling characters. It's what sets them apart from the countless clichés and stereotypes that populate fiction. A truly original character is one who surprises you, challenges your assumptions, and leaves a lasting impression. Avoid the temptation to simply rehash familiar tropes and archetypes. Instead, strive to create a character that is fresh, unique, and authentically themselves. Think about what makes your character different from everyone else. What are their quirks and eccentricities? What are their passions and interests? What are their unique talents and skills? These details will help you create a character that is truly one-of-a-kind. It's also important to consider your character's perspective on the world. How do they see things differently from others? What are their unique insights and observations? A character's perspective can be a powerful tool for storytelling, allowing you to explore new themes and ideas in a fresh and engaging way. Don’t be afraid to take risks and challenge conventions. Some of the most memorable characters are the ones who break the mold and defy expectations. Think about characters like Lisbeth Salander from The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo – she's a hacker, a vigilante, and a survivor of abuse, but she's also fiercely independent, intelligent, and loyal to those she cares about. Her unique personality and perspective are what make her such a compelling character. Originality is not just about creating a character who is different for the sake of being different – it's about creating a character who is authentic, believable, and deeply human. It's about giving them a voice, a perspective, and a story that is all their own. The more original your character is, the more likely they are to resonate with audiences and leave a lasting impact.

Let Them Evolve

Your OC shouldn't be the same at the end of the story as they were at the beginning. Allow them to grow, change, and learn from their experiences. How do they respond to challenges? How do their relationships evolve? Character evolution is the engine of compelling storytelling. It's the process by which a character changes, grows, and develops over the course of a story. A character who remains the same from beginning to end is often seen as flat and uninteresting, lacking the depth and complexity that make them relatable to audiences. Think about the challenges that your character will face throughout the story. How will these challenges impact them? How will they grow and change as a result? Will they overcome their flaws and weaknesses? Will they learn from their mistakes? These questions will help you create a dynamic and engaging character arc. It's also important to consider the impact of your character's relationships on their evolution. How do their interactions with others shape their personality and worldview? Do they learn from the people around them? Do they inspire others to change and grow? A character's relationships can be a powerful catalyst for evolution, providing opportunities for conflict, growth, and healing. Don’t be afraid to let your character make mistakes and experience setbacks. Failure is an essential part of the growth process. It's through our failures that we learn the most about ourselves and the world around us. A character who never fails is often seen as unrealistic and unrelatable. Let your character stumble, fall, and make bad decisions, but also give them the opportunity to learn from their mistakes and emerge stronger and wiser. Remember, character evolution is not a linear process. It's a complex and often messy journey, with twists, turns, and unexpected detours. Your character may experience moments of regression, self-doubt, and even despair, but it's through these struggles that they ultimately find their true strength and potential. The more your character evolves, the more compelling their story will become. A character who has undergone a significant transformation is often seen as more relatable, more inspiring, and more human.

Final Thoughts: Embrace the Challenge

Creating amazing OCs is a challenging but rewarding process. By understanding the pitfalls and embracing thoughtful development, you can create characters that resonate with audiences and bring your stories to life. So go forth, create, and have fun!